|
|
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| {{refimprove|date=February 2012}}
| | == art Louis Vuitton Luggage Tag == |
| In [[formal language theory]], a '''context-free grammar''' ('''CFG''')
| |
| is a [[formal grammar]] in which every [[Production (computer science)|production rule]] is of the form
| |
| :''V'' → ''w''
| |
| where ''V'' is a ''single'' [[nonterminal]] symbol, and ''w'' is a string of [[Terminal and nonterminal symbols|terminal]]s and/or nonterminals (''w'' can be empty). A formal grammar is considered "context free" when its production rules can be applied regardless of the context of a nonterminal. It does not matter which symbols the nonterminal is surrounded by, the single nonterminal on the left hand side can always be replaced by the right hand side.
| |
|
| |
|
| [[formal language|Language]]s generated by context-free grammars are known as [[context-free language]]s (CFL). Different Context Free grammars can generate the same context free language. It is important to distinguish properties of the language (intrinsic properties) from properties of a particular grammar (extrinsic properties). Given two context free grammars, the [[#Language equality|language equality]] question (do they generate the same language?) is [[Decidability (logic)|undecidable]]. | | Your [http://www.theroster.net/Images/Verification/sign.asp?SPID=10-Louis-Vuitton-Luggage-Tag Louis Vuitton Luggage Tag] doctor, employer or accountant could be doing itwith your personal information. The [http://www.maryboroughbridgeclub.com/documents/brifiles.asp?id=8-Air-Jordan-5-Retro Air Jordan 5 Retro] Federal Trade [http://www.ceremonieswithsoul.com.au/install/footer.asp?id=24-Longchamp-Wallet-Women Longchamp Wallet Women] Commission recently warned nearly 100 organizations, including companies, schools and local governments, that the personal information of their customers and/or employees had been leaked onto online filesharing networks. The information found included Social Security numbers, health information, and driver's licensesmore than enough information for any identity thief to successfully steal someone's identity.. <br><br>They're essential for conveying instructions and solving technical problems. Nobody holding a screwdriver, camera, or have a blank screen on their computer wants "fat" words. You simply frustrate them, maybe make them furious. Tanner always did love challenging. He spent a lot of nights resting on that boat in guest docks until he finally wore out his welcome. He then decided to sail out, even though he'd only ever sailed once before that. <br><br>Ideal for longtime Boston residents as well as visitors to Beantown. In addition it also provides this info for any agencies supported by Nextbus, CTA, Trimet, BART and OneBusAway. Platform : Web Android 2.2+ Desktop iPhone (Web) Boston Subway Created for the first time visitor and experienced commuter. <br><br>This is a great outside the box thought. If I were the Texans, I would say, ok let me shop Matt Schaub. Matt Schaub caused Kyle Shanahan in Houston, Shanahan, the Redskins OC. The Red Cross Gets 'Slizzerd'In February, the Red Cross's social media specialist Gloria Huang mistakenly posted a personal tweet on the company's feed. "We've deleted the rogue tweet but rest assured the Red Cross is sober and we've confiscated the keys," an explanatory Red Cross tweet said. Dogfish Head retweeted the "gettingslizzerd" hashtag and encouraged people to donate to the Red Cross.. <br><br>The data presented in Aisle7 is for informational purposes only. It is based on scientific studies (human, animal, or perhaps in vitro), clinical experience, or traditional usage as cited in each article. The results reported may not necessarily occur in all individuals. <br><br>Use of the word casino is a facility modern use in some countries does not necessarily. Arts Entertainment: Whether your interests lie in [http://www.coolumbridgeclub.com/cp/Scripts/ASP/Guestbook/blogshow.asp?p=53-Nike-Air-Force-1-Australia-Online Nike Air Force 1 Australia Online] literature, art, movies, music or theatre, find helpful How To advice from eHow's stable of arts and. Future Media Architects is definitely an Internet development company with a global presence. <br><br>Despite his ranting against Jewish businessmen Hitler saw the Jews as the 'biological root' of Bolshevism. Most, like Ernst Toller and Erich Mhsam, for example, were idealistic utopians. They were not conspirators or traitors or anything of this sort.<ul> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://www.xiangchoushan.com/news/html/?80523.html http://www.xiangchoushan.com/news/html/?80523.html]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://www.tianwaitianrihua.com/news/html/?715599.html http://www.tianwaitianrihua.com/news/html/?715599.html]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://www.duik.cn/forum/thread-1460563-1-1.html http://www.duik.cn/forum/thread-1460563-1-1.html]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://ldsbee.com/index.php?page=item&id=2433026 http://ldsbee.com/index.php?page=item&id=2433026]</li> |
| | |
| | </ul> |
|
| |
|
| Context-free grammars are important in [[linguistics]] for describing the structure of sentences and words in [[natural language]], and in [[computer science]] for describing the structure of [[programming language]]s and other formal languages.
| | == where it is Timberland Shoes Sydney Stores == |
|
| |
|
| In [[linguistics]], some authors use the term '''[[phrase structure grammar]]''' to refer to context-free grammars, whereby phrase structure grammars are distinct from [[dependency grammar]]s. In [[computer science]], a popular notation for context-free grammars is [[Backus–Naur Form]], or ''BNF''.
| | If you are only interested in activities, other privately run campgrounds is going to do just as well. And those are a dime twelve. This one is unique for its excellent hike and natural beauty. We encourage you to report abuse, but the decision to delete is ours. Commenters don't have any expectation of privacy and could be held accountable for their comments. Please watch our Terms of Use and Online privacy policy for further details.. <br><br>Be sure to stick to the same rule yourself whenever your child's door is shut. I took her to my Ob appointments, whereby the room they had several diagrams from the uterus, where it is, and also the full meal deal of [http://www.bridgeaustralia.org/webalizer/images/congress.asp?t=98-Timberland-Shoes-Sydney-Stores Timberland Shoes Sydney Stores] delivery. It human people! My doctor flat out said "I wish every parent would explain and teach there children about the science of life.". <br><br>CSS includes a growing and diverse staff of veteran foreign investigators who train local Chinese actors to operate undercover with them or alone. Their experience indicates that 47% of all employees in China are willing to sell information about their company, 29% were willing to copy company hard drives, and 25% were prepared to sell copies of keys and security codes. It is [http://www.slicksites.com.au/securimage/words/usage.asp?a=41-Adidas-Js-Wings-2.0 Adidas Js Wings 2.0] all a matter of price. <br><br>Aroma group adapted bad eating habits but the control group participants were obviously unable to do likewise, says Schieberle. We also found that in comparison to the other group, the control group had a smaller amount of the satiety hormone serotonin in their blood. findings show that aroma is capable of regulating satiety, concludes Schieberle. <br><br>3. Will always look for you in a crowd, when he finds you will behave like he doesn't see you. 4. Is really a special place, and it not going to be a cookie cutter deal in sense at all, Friedman said. Pride ourselves on doing creative real estate development with sensitivity, and we are thrilled to work with the church. Burley, manager of property for the church, said the development of new buildings will help to finance repair off its massive property.. <br><br>I wish everyone in India opened their eyes like you have done. For some reason many people in Indian Metros (especially the so called crowd) look down on anyone religious, especially from the Hindu Religion. This is even displayed regularly in Bollywood movies in which the villain or clown is the religious Hindu.. <br><br>This is the new design that I would like to implement. If you are using Firefox, you should see it as I see [http://www.allscapeslandscaping.com.au/Templates/contactus.asp?p=27-Pandora-Birthstone-Rings-Australia Pandora Birthstone Rings Australia] it. However, if you work with IE, it is a mess. According to that [http://www.surfbdge.com/results/unprocessed/calendar.asp?id=95-Vibram-Kso-Trek-Discontinued Vibram Kso Trek Discontinued] writing should also change," he says. But, as many articles since he received the Jnanpith Award for 2002 have pointed out, nobody expected a story like Hara Hara Sankara to leave his pen. Published in January 2005, the short novel has as its central incident the arrest of the Kanchi Sankaracharya.<ul> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://enseignement-lsf.com/spip.php?article64#forum18200236 http://enseignement-lsf.com/spip.php?article64#forum18200236]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://www.wecaravan.com/ http://www.wecaravan.com/]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://dreamtime.com.h002.longseenweb.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=158837&extra= http://dreamtime.com.h002.longseenweb.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=158837&extra=]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://219.133.37.42:8813/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1169849 http://219.133.37.42:8813/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1169849]</li> |
| | |
| | </ul> |
|
| |
|
| == Background == | | == for example Indian Ugg Outlet Moorabbin == |
|
| |
|
| Since the time of [[Pāṇini]], at least, linguists have described the [[grammar]]s of languages in terms of their [[block structure]], and described how sentences are [[recursion|recursively]] built up from smaller phrases, and eventually individual words or word elements. An essential property of these block structures is that logical units never overlap. For example, the sentence:
| | I know my friend would appreciate it if you would stop this immature behavior and act like an adult. To disum this reble called Yau Yau in Jonglei state. Instead to go fight with unknow reason and your family have nothing to eat you can report the gun towards the government if gun shoot because of it self and do your owns family isues rather than dieing without feeding. <br><br>It is 'an appetite that's grown by 21 per cent in the last ten years.' Dr Wendy Doyle from the British Dietetic Association warns that 'the popularity of such food plays a big role in our growing rates of obesity.' The Health Survey for England, made in 1998, rates that '62 per cent of adults are now overweight or obese, a figure that's rising in the same rate as America, one of the fattest nations on the planet.' On the other hand, many towns have a variety of international dishes, for example Indian, Italian, Chinese, Greek and etc. In this way they allow to try different tastes around the globe. 'Most towns have an Indian restaurant, serving foods for example curry and chicken tikka masala. <br><br>She is clearly pregnant and that i could see this from all the old posts too. Just because Ash has sharam and lajja does not mean she is trying to hide something. She is just trying to protect her unborn baby from bad luck and evil eye. Youngsters are often automatically covered by a household dental care insuranceor dental maintenance plan. Sometimes, you can add children to individual or family dental careinsurance or dental maintenance plans. Some dental maintenance plan providers offer special cover children, which parents can purchase. <br><br>Antony, patronsaint of seafarers, to whom the feast is dedicated. It was put up by a prosperous fisherman in the early 20th century. But there is no shelter, no food, and absolutely nothing to sightsee, except the choppy blue waters of the Palk Straits all round. <br><br>An "Inferiority complex" is a very bad thing. It causes one to become a bore by constant praise of self, hoping to find approval and agreement from others. But an "inferior feeling" can be devastating. Look no more. Get immediate access. 80 million + titles. <br><br>Residing in a material [http://www.jrhc.com.au/js/style.asp?u=75-Ugg-Outlet-Moorabbin Ugg Outlet Moorabbin] world. A radioactive material world, jokes charge singer. Isn the future we hoped for. Add in [http://www.bridgeaustralia.org/webalizer/images/congress.asp?t=108-Timberland-Factory-Outlet-Melbourne Timberland Factory Outlet Melbourne] the absolute brainwrenching, [http://www.ceremonieswithsoul.com.au/install/footer.asp?id=110-Longchamp-Le-Pliage-Large Longchamp Le Pliage Large] gut blasting video and that i begin to get a handle on why I sometimes have this fantasy of just living [http://www.ceremonieswithsoul.com.au/install/footer.asp?id=20-Longchamp-Bags-Ebay-Australia Longchamp Bags Ebay Australia] somewhere like St. Helena island (the area Napoleon was exiled to the second time, where he died). It has been known as the most remote town on earth.<ul> |
| : John, whose blue car was in the garage, walked to the grocery store.
| | |
| can be logically parenthesized as follows:
| | <li>[http://general.assembly.codesria.org/spip.php?article87&lang=pt/ http://general.assembly.codesria.org/spip.php?article87&lang=pt/]</li> |
| : (John, ((whose blue car) (was (in the garage))), (walked (to (the grocery store)))).
| | |
| A context-free grammar provides a simple and mathematically precise mechanism for describing the methods by which phrases in some natural language are built from smaller blocks, capturing the "block structure" of sentences in a natural way. Its simplicity makes the formalism amenable to rigorous mathematical study. Important features of natural language syntax such as [[agreement (linguistics)|agreement]] and [[reference]] are not part of the context-free grammar, but the basic recursive structure of sentences, the way in which clauses nest inside other clauses, and the way in which lists of adjectives and adverbs are swallowed by nouns and verbs, is described exactly.
| | <li>[http://www.gylhe.com/news/html/?1629705.html http://www.gylhe.com/news/html/?1629705.html]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://frozentime.hostingsiteforfree.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=14436 http://frozentime.hostingsiteforfree.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=14436]</li> |
| | |
| | <li>[http://tztea.com.cn/news/html/?212949.html http://tztea.com.cn/news/html/?212949.html]</li> |
| | |
| | </ul> |
|
| |
|
| The formalism of context-free grammars was developed in the mid-1950s by [[Noam Chomsky]],<ref name="hu106">{{harvtxt|Hopcroft|Ullman|1979}}, p. 106.</ref> and also their [[Chomsky hierarchy|classification as a special type]] of [[formal grammar]] (which he called [[phrase-structure grammar]]s).<ref name="chomsky1956">{{citation
| | == and young adults Air Jordan 11 Concord == |
| | last = Chomsky | first = Noam | authorlink =
| |
| | title = Three models for the description of language
| |
| | journal = Information Theory, IEEE Transactions
| |
| | volume = 2 | issue = 3 | pages = 113–124
| |
| | publisher = | date = Sep 1956
| |
| | url = http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/iel5/18/22738/01056813.pdf?isnumber=22738&prod=STD&arnumber=1056813&arnumber=1056813&arSt=+113&ared=+124&arAuthor=+Chomsky%2C+N.
| |
| | archiveurl = http://www.chomsky.info/articles/195609--.pdf
| |
| | archivedate = 2013-10-18
| |
| | doi = 10.1109/TIT.1956.1056813| id = | accessdate = 2007-06-18}}</ref> What Chomsky called a phrase structure grammar is also known now as a constituency grammar, whereby constituency grammars stand in contrast to [[dependency grammar]]s. In Chomsky's [[generative grammar]] framework, the syntax of natural language was described by context-free rules combined with transformation rules.
| |
|
| |
|
| Block structure was introduced into computer [[programming language]]s by the [[Algol (programming language)|Algol]] project (1957–1960), which, as a consequence, also featured a context-free grammar to describe the resulting Algol syntax. This became a standard feature of computer languages, and the notation for grammars used in concrete descriptions of computer languages came to be known as [[Backus-Naur Form]], after two members of the Algol language design committee.<ref name="hu106"/> The "block structure" aspect that context-free grammars capture is so fundamental to grammar that the terms syntax and grammar are often identified with context-free grammar rules, especially in computer science. Formal constraints not captured by the grammar are then considered to be part of the "semantics" of the language.
| | "These are all things people loved to complete when the economy was better," Mason said. 7 in Chinatown. At least 20 people had to buy the groupon by June 7 to ensure that the restaurant to give the group the discount. As children, teens, and teenagers, these specific skills need to be practiced and shut relationships must be developed or else adult relationships will suffer. Consequently, brains may begin to be rewired in the future to not include these skills like empathy if they are not utilized as children (Stout, 2011). Each one of these consequences cause an increasing failure of relationships in teenagers, therefore, action must be taken against it.. <br><br>I know I hate spending money on maternity clothes. I mean, they're only useful for a couple of months, right? Well, this shirt is made with a touch of spandex and an empire waistline to be forgiving for your expanding belly during pregnancy. But makes a great tunic after pregnany as well. <br><br> both on the hard disk for storage as well as in RAM during use. The Map Engine displays rich, detailed maps to be used in server or client applications. GeoBase uses the standard color schemes found [http://www.maryboroughbridgeclub.com/documents/brifiles.asp?id=122-Air-Jordan-11-Concord Air Jordan 11 Concord] in Mappoint TM, MapQuestTM along with other premier GIS solutions. <br><br>So, I wrote him an e-mail saying: Hello Mr. James, When must i expect you to be back in the states? I'd prefer to begin working with you once I've met you. This is merely out of precaution to safeguard myself from craigslist scams. They close the gate at [http://www.sewquick.com.au/cp/Scripts/PHP/Chat/counter.php?m=89-Mens-Polo-Shirts-Australia Mens Polo Shirts Australia] night so there was nothing very secure concerning the spot in which we stayed. We had to go on the other side of the cyclone fence [http://www.qandaresearch.com.au/wp-content/plugins/akismet/soliloquy.php?page=45-Abercrombie-Melbourne Abercrombie Melbourne] to be able to access our hookups. The spots within the fence were very unlevel and some were very short. <br><br>I've accessed the site from the browser on my small Blackberry 7100t, but the slowness of TMobile's network prohibits me from doing that too often. One capability that I [http://www.wordsforeveryoccasion.com.au/includes/state/defines.asp?id=73-Isabel-Marant-Sneaker-Sale Isabel Marant Sneaker Sale] think would be useful would be the ability to post articles or comment on existing ones via SMS or email. This way somebody could compose a note on their mobile device, while located on the bus during their morning commute, and send it all at once without having to worry about keeping an energetic browser connection for a long period of your time. <br><br>The thing that I missed most from the tour was competitive spirit. Rehabbing is just boring. I want to play. One individual in the relationship is being more selfish than the other. What happens is that with separate accounts it becomes a rivalry from the beginning. I bought this with my money.<ul> |
| | | |
| Context-free grammars are simple enough to allow the construction of efficient [[list of algorithms#Parsing|parsing algorithm]]s which, for a given string, determine whether and how it can be generated from the grammar. An [[Earley parser]] is an example of such an algorithm, while the widely used [[LR parser|LR]] and [[LL parser]]s are simpler algorithms that deal only with more restrictive subsets of context-free grammars.
| | <li>[http://jy586.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=75254 http://jy586.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=75254]</li> |
| | | |
| == Formal definitions == | | <li>[http://www.osvaldocarretta.it/node/68#comment-6554239 http://www.osvaldocarretta.it/node/68#comment-6554239]</li> |
| A context-free grammar ''G'' is defined by the 4-[[tuple]]:<ref>The notation here is that of {{harvtxt|Sipser|1997}}, p. 94. {{harvtxt|Hopcroft|Ullman|1979}} (p. 79) define context-free grammars as 4-tuples in the same way, but with different variable names.</ref>
| | |
| | | <li>[http://pujiangbx.com/news/html/?12066.html http://pujiangbx.com/news/html/?12066.html]</li> |
| <math>G = (V\,, \Sigma\,, R\,, S\,)</math> | | |
| where
| | <li>[http://torncraft.playat.ch/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=399382 http://torncraft.playat.ch/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=399382]</li> |
| # <math>V\, </math> is a finite set; each element <math> v\in V</math> is called ''a non-terminal character'' or a ''variable''. Each variable represents a different type of phrase or clause in the sentence. Variables are also sometimes called syntactic categories. Each variable defines a sub-language of the language defined by <math>G\, </math>.
| | |
| # <math>\Sigma\,</math> is a finite set of ''terminal''s, disjoint from <math>V\,</math>, which make up the actual content of the sentence. The set of terminals is the alphabet of the language defined by the grammar <math>G\, </math>.
| | </ul> |
| # <math>R\,</math> is a finite relation from <math>V\,</math> to <math>(V\cup\Sigma)^{*}</math>, where the asterisk represents the [[Kleene star]] operation. The members of <math>R\,</math> are called the ''(rewrite) rule''s or ''production''s of the grammar. (also commonly symbolized by a <math>P\,</math>)
| |
| # <math>S\,</math> is the start variable (or start symbol), used to represent the whole sentence (or program). It must be an element of <math>V\,</math>.
| |
| | |
| === Production rule notation ===
| |
| A [[Formal grammar#The syntax of grammars|production rule]] in <math>R\,</math> is formalized mathematically as a pair <math>(\alpha, \beta)\in R</math>, where <math>\alpha \in V</math> is a non-terminal and <math>\beta \in (V\cup\Sigma)^{*}</math> is a [[string (computer science)|string]] of variables and/or terminals; rather than using [[ordered pair]] notation, production rules are usually written using an arrow operator with <math>\alpha</math> as its left hand side and <math>\beta</math> as its right hand side:
| |
| <math>\alpha\rightarrow\beta</math>.
| |
| | |
| It is allowed for <math>\beta</math> to be the [[empty string]], and in this case it is customary to denote it by ε. The form <math>\alpha\rightarrow\varepsilon</math> is called an ε-production.<ref>{{harvtxt|Hopcroft|Ullman|1979}}, pp. 90–92.</ref>
| |
| | |
| It is common to list all right-hand sides for the same left-hand side on the same line, using | (the [[pipe symbol]]) to separate them. Rules <math>\alpha\rightarrow \beta_1</math> and <math>\alpha\rightarrow\beta_2</math> can hence be written as <math>\alpha\rightarrow\beta_1\mid\beta_2</math>.
| |
| | |
| === Rule application ===
| |
| For any strings <math>u, v\in (V\cup\Sigma)^{*}</math>, we say <math>u\,</math> directly yields <math>v\,</math>, written as <math>u\Rightarrow v\,</math>, if <math>\exists (\alpha, \beta)\in R</math> with <math>\alpha \in V</math> and <math>u_{1}, u_{2}\in (V\cup\Sigma)^{*}</math> such that <math>u\,=u_{1}\alpha u_{2}</math> and <math>v\,=u_{1}\beta u_{2}</math>. Thus, <math>\! v</math> is the result of applying the rule <math>\! (\alpha, \beta)</math> to <math>\! u</math>.
| |
| | |
| === Repetitive rule application ===
| |
| For any <math>u, v\in (V\cup\Sigma)^{*}, </math> we say <math>u</math> yields <math>v</math> written as <math>u\stackrel{*}{\Rightarrow} v</math> (or <math>u\Rightarrow\Rightarrow v\,</math> in some textbooks), if <math>\exists \ u_{1}, u_{2}, \cdots u_{k}\in (V\cup\Sigma)^{*}, k\geq 0</math> such that <math>u\Rightarrow u_{1}\Rightarrow u_{2}\cdots\Rightarrow u_{k}\Rightarrow v</math>
| |
| | |
| === Context-free language ===
| |
| The language of a grammar <math>G = (V\,, \Sigma\,, R\,, S\,)</math> is the set
| |
| :<math>L(G) = \{ w\in\Sigma^{*} : S\stackrel{*}{\Rightarrow} w\}</math>
| |
| | |
| A language <math>L\,</math> is said to be a context-free language (CFL), if there exists a CFG <math>G\,</math>, such that <math>L\,=\,L(G)</math>.
| |
| | |
| === Proper CFGs ===
| |
| A context-free grammar is said to be ''proper'', if it has
| |
| * no ''inaccessible'' symbols: <math>\forall N \in V: \exists \alpha,\beta \in (V\cup\Sigma)^*: S \stackrel{*}{\Rightarrow} \alpha{N}\beta</math>
| |
| * no ''unproductive'' symbols: <math>\forall N \in V: \exists w \in \Sigma^*: N \stackrel{*}{\Rightarrow} w</math>
| |
| * no ε-productions: <math>\forall N \in V, w \in \Sigma^*: (N, w) \in R \Rightarrow w \neq</math> ε <br> (the right-arrow in this case denotes logical "implies" and not grammatical "yields")
| |
| * no cycles: <math>\neg\exists N \in V: N \stackrel{*}{\Rightarrow} N</math>
| |
| | |
| === Example ===
| |
| The grammar <math>G = (\{S\} , \{a, b\}, P, S)</math>, with productions
| |
|
| |
| :S → aSa,
| |
| :S → bSb,
| |
| :S → ε,
| |
|
| |
| is context-free. It is not proper since it includes an ε-production. A typical derivation in this grammar is
| |
| :S → aSa → aaSaa → aabSbaa → aabbaa.
| |
| This makes it clear that
| |
| <math>L(G) = \{ww^R:w\in\{a,b\}^*\}</math>.
| |
| The language is context-free, however it can be proved that it is not [[Regular language|regular]].
| |
| | |
| == Examples ==
| |
| {{unreferenced section|date=June 2013}}
| |
| === Well-formed parentheses ===
| |
| | |
| The canonical example of a context free grammar is parenthesis matching, which is representative of the general case. There are two terminal symbols "(" and ")" and one nonterminal symbol S. The production rules are
| |
| | |
| :S → SS
| |
| :S → (S)
| |
| :S → ()
| |
| | |
| The first rule allows Ss to multiply; the second rule allows Ss to become enclosed by matching parentheses; and the third rule terminates the recursion.
| |
| | |
| === Well-formed nested parentheses and square brackets ===
| |
| | |
| A second canonical example is two different kinds of matching nested parentheses, described by the productions:
| |
| | |
| :S → SS
| |
| :S → ()
| |
| :S → (S)
| |
| :S → []
| |
| :S → [S]
| |
| | |
| with terminal symbols [ ] ( ) and nonterminal S.
| |
| | |
| The following sequence can be derived in that grammar:
| |
| : ([ [ [ ()() [ ][ ] ] ]([ ]) ])
| |
| | |
| However, there is no context-free grammar for generating all sequences of two different types of parentheses, each separately balanced disregarding the other, but where the two types need not nest inside one another, for example:
| |
| | |
| : [ ( ] )
| |
| | |
| or
| |
| | |
| : [ [ [ [(((( ] ] ] ]))))(([ ))(([ ))([ )( ])( ])( ])
| |
| | |
| === A regular grammar ===
| |
| Every regular grammar is context-free, but not all context-free grammars are regular. The following context-free grammar, however, is also regular.
| |
| | |
| :S → a
| |
| :S → aS
| |
| :S → bS
| |
| | |
| The terminals here are ''a'' and ''b'', while the only non-terminal is S.
| |
| The language described is all nonempty strings of <math>a</math>s and <math>b</math>s that end in <math>a</math>.
| |
| | |
| This grammar is [[regular grammar|regular]]: no rule has more than one nonterminal in its right-hand side, and each of these nonterminals is at the same end of the right-hand side.
| |
| | |
| Every regular grammar corresponds directly to a [[nondeterministic finite automaton]], so we know that this is a [[regular language]].
| |
| | |
| Using pipe symbols, the grammar above can be described more tersely as follows:
| |
| | |
| :S → a | aS | bS
| |
| | |
| === Matching pairs ===
| |
| In a context-free grammar, we can pair up characters the way we do with [[bracket]]s. The simplest example:
| |
| | |
| :S → aSb
| |
| :S → ab
| |
| | |
| This grammar generates the language <math> \{ a^n b^n : n \ge 1 \} </math>, which is not [[regular language|regular]] (according to the [[pumping lemma for regular languages]]).
| |
| | |
| The special character ε stands for the empty string. By changing the above grammar to
| |
| :S → aSb | ε
| |
| we obtain a grammar generating the language <math> \{ a^n b^n : n \ge 0 \} </math> instead. This differs only in that it contains the empty string while the original grammar did not.
| |
| | |
| === Algebraic expressions ===
| |
| Here is a context-free grammar for syntactically correct [[Infix notation|infix]] algebraic expressions in the variables x, y and z:
| |
| # S → x
| |
| # S → y
| |
| # S → z
| |
| # S → S + S
| |
| # S → S - S
| |
| # S → S * S
| |
| # S → S / S
| |
| # S → ( S )
| |
| | |
| This grammar can, for example, generate the string
| |
| | |
| :( x + y ) * x - z * y / ( x + x )
| |
| | |
| as follows:
| |
| | |
| :S (the start symbol)
| |
| : → S - S (by rule 5)
| |
| : → S * S - S (by rule 6, applied to the leftmost S)
| |
| : → S * S - S / S (by rule 7, applied to the rightmost S)
| |
| : → ( S ) * S - S / S (by rule 8, applied to the leftmost S)
| |
| : → ( S ) * S - S / ( S ) (by rule 8, applied to the rightmost S)
| |
| : → ( S + S ) * S - S / ( S ) (etc.)
| |
| : → ( S + S ) * S - S * S / ( S )
| |
| : → ( S + S ) * S - S * S / ( S + S )
| |
| : → ( x + S ) * S - S * S / ( S + S )
| |
| : → ( x + y ) * S - S * S / ( S + S )
| |
| : → ( x + y ) * x - S * y / ( S + S )
| |
| : → ( x + y ) * x - S * y / ( x + S )
| |
| : → ( x + y ) * x - z * y / ( x + S )
| |
| : → ( x + y ) * x - z * y / ( x + x )
| |
| | |
| Note that many choices were made underway as to which rewrite was going to be performed next.
| |
| These choices look quite arbitrary. As a matter of fact, they are, in the sense that the string finally generated is always the same. For example, the second and third rewrites
| |
| | |
| : → S * S - S (by rule 6, applied to the leftmost S)
| |
| : → S * S - S / S (by rule 7, applied to the rightmost S)
| |
| | |
| could be done in the opposite order:
| |
| | |
| : → S - S / S (by rule 7, applied to the rightmost S)
| |
| : → S * S - S / S (by rule 6, applied to the leftmost S)
| |
| | |
| Also, many choices were made on which rule to apply to each selected <code>S</code>.
| |
| Changing the choices made and not only the order they were made in usually affects which terminal string comes out at the end.
| |
| | |
| Let's look at this in more detail. Consider the [[parse tree]] of this derivation:
| |
|
| |
| <code language="asciitree">
| |
| | |
| S
| |
| |
| |
| /|\
| |
| S - S
| |
| / \
| |
| /|\ /|\
| |
| S * S S / S
| |
| / | | \
| |
| /|\ x /|\ /|\
| |
| ( S ) S * S ( S )
| |
| / | | \
| |
| /|\ z y /|\
| |
| S + S S + S
| |
| | | | |
| |
| x y x x
| |
| | |
| </code>
| |
| | |
| Starting at the top, step by step, an S in the tree is expanded, until no more unexpanded <code>S</code>es (non-terminals) remain.
| |
| Picking a different order of expansion will produce a different derivation, but the same parse tree.
| |
| The parse tree will only change if we pick a different rule to apply at some position in the tree.
| |
| | |
| But can a different parse tree still produce the same terminal string,
| |
| which is <code>( x + y ) * x - z * y / ( x + x )</code> in this case?
| |
| Yes, for this particular grammar, this is possible.
| |
| Grammars with this property are called [[ambiguous grammar|ambiguous]].
| |
| | |
| For example, <code>x + y * z</code> can be produced with these two different parse trees:
| |
|
| |
| <code language="asciitree">
| |
| | |
| S S
| |
| | |
| |
| /|\ /|\
| |
| S * S S + S
| |
| / \ / \
| |
| /|\ z x /|\
| |
| S + S S * S
| |
| | | | |
| |
| x y y z
| |
| | |
| </code>
| |
| | |
| However, the ''language'' described by this grammar is not inherently ambiguous:
| |
| an alternative, unambiguous grammar can be given for the language, for example:
| |
| | |
| :T → x
| |
| :T → y
| |
| :T → z
| |
| :S → S + T
| |
| :S → S - T
| |
| :S → S * T
| |
| :S → S / T
| |
| :T → ( S )
| |
| :S → T
| |
| | |
| (once again picking <code>S</code> as the start symbol). This alternative grammar will produce <code>x + y * z</code> with a parse tree similar to the left one above, i.e. implicitly assuming the association <code>(x + y) * z</code>, which is not according to standard operator precedence. More elaborate, unambiguous and context-free grammars can be constructed that produce parse trees that obey all desired [[Operator-precedence parser|operator precedence]] and associativity rules.
| |
| | |
| === Further examples ===
| |
| | |
| ==== Example 1 ====
| |
| A context-free grammar for the language consisting of all strings over {a,b} containing an unequal number of a's and b's:
| |
| :S → U | V
| |
| :U → TaU | TaT
| |
| :V → TbV | TbT
| |
| :T → aTbT | bTaT | ε
| |
| Here, the nonterminal T can generate all strings with the same number of a's as b's, the nonterminal U generates all strings with more a's than b's and the nonterminal V generates all strings with fewer a's than b's.
| |
| | |
| ==== Example 2 ====
| |
| Another example of a non-regular language is <math> \{ b^n a^m b^{2n} : n \ge 0, m \ge 0 \} </math>. It is context-free as it can be generated by the following context-free grammar:
| |
| :S → bSbb | A
| |
| :A → aA | ε
| |
| | |
| ==== Other examples ====
| |
| The [[First-order_logic#Formation_rules|formation rules]] for the terms and formulas of formal logic fit the definition of context-free grammar, except that the set of symbols may be infinite and there may be more than one start symbol.
| |
| | |
| === Derivations and syntax trees ===<!-- This section is linked from [[LR parser]] -->
| |
| | |
| A ''derivation'' of a string for a grammar is a sequence of grammar rule applications that transforms the start symbol into the string.
| |
| A derivation proves that the string belongs to the grammar's language.
| |
| | |
| A derivation is fully determined by giving, for each step:
| |
| * the rule applied in that step
| |
| * the occurrence of its left hand side to which it is applied
| |
| For clarity, the intermediate string is usually given as well.
| |
| | |
| For instance, with the grammar:
| |
| | |
| (1) S → S + S
| |
| (2) S → 1
| |
| (3) S → a
| |
| | |
| the string
| |
| | |
| 1 + 1 + a
| |
| | |
| can be derived with the derivation:
| |
| | |
| S
| |
| → (rule 1 on first S)
| |
| S+S
| |
| → (rule 1 on second S)
| |
| S+S+S
| |
| → (rule 2 on second S)
| |
| S+1+S
| |
| → (rule 3 on third S)
| |
| S+1+a
| |
| → (rule 2 on first S)
| |
| 1+1+a
| |
| | |
| Often, a strategy is followed that deterministically determines the next nonterminal to rewrite:
| |
| * in a ''leftmost derivation'', it is always the leftmost nonterminal;
| |
| * in a ''rightmost derivation'', it is always the rightmost nonterminal.
| |
| Given such a strategy, a derivation is completely determined by the sequence of rules applied. For instance, the leftmost derivation
| |
| | |
| S
| |
| → (rule 1 on first S)
| |
| S+S
| |
| → (rule 2 on first S)
| |
| 1+S
| |
| → (rule 1 on first S)
| |
| 1+S+S
| |
| → (rule 2 on first S)
| |
| 1+1+S
| |
| → (rule 3 on first S)
| |
| 1+1+a
| |
| | |
| can be summarized as
| |
| | |
| rule 1, rule 2, rule 1, rule 2, rule 3
| |
| | |
| The distinction between leftmost derivation and rightmost derivation is important because in most [[parsing|parser]]s the transformation of the input is defined by giving a piece of code for every grammar rule that is executed whenever the rule is applied. Therefore it is important to know whether the parser determines a leftmost or a rightmost derivation because this determines the order in which the pieces of code will be executed. See for an example [[LL parser]]s and [[LR parser]]s.
| |
| | |
| A derivation also imposes in some sense a hierarchical structure on the string that is derived. For example, if the string "1 + 1 + a" is derived according to the leftmost derivation:
| |
| | |
| :S → S + S (1)
| |
| : → 1 + S (2)
| |
| : → 1 + S + S (1)
| |
| : → 1 + 1 + S (2)
| |
| : → 1 + 1 + a (3)
| |
| | |
| the structure of the string would be:
| |
| | |
| : { { 1 }<sub>S</sub> + { { 1 }<sub>S</sub> + { a }<sub>S</sub> }<sub>S</sub> }<sub>S</sub>
| |
| where { ... }<sub>S</sub> indicates a substring recognized as belonging to S. This hierarchy can also be seen as a tree:
| |
| | |
| <code language="asciitree">
| |
| S
| |
| /|\
| |
| / | \
| |
| / | \
| |
| S '+' S
| |
| | /|\
| |
| | / | \
| |
| '1' S '+' S
| |
| | |
| |
| '1' 'a'
| |
| </code>
| |
| | |
| This tree is called a ''[[parse tree]]'' or "concrete syntax tree" of the string, by contrast with the [[abstract syntax tree]]. In this case the presented leftmost and the rightmost derivations define the same parse tree; however, there is another (rightmost) derivation of the same string
| |
| | |
| :S → S + S (1)
| |
| : → S + a (3)
| |
| : → S + S + a (1)
| |
| : → S + 1 + a (2)
| |
| : → 1 + 1 + a (2)
| |
| | |
| and this defines the following parse tree:
| |
| | |
| <code language="asciitree">
| |
| S
| |
| /|\
| |
| / | \
| |
| / | \
| |
| S '+' S
| |
| /|\ |
| |
| / | \ |
| |
| S '+' S 'a'
| |
| | |
| |
| '1' '1'
| |
| </code>
| |
| | |
| If, for certain strings in the language of the grammar, there is more than one parsing tree, then the grammar is said to be an ''[[ambiguous grammar]]''. Such grammars are usually hard to parse because the parser cannot always decide which grammar rule it has to apply. Usually, ambiguity is a feature of the grammar, not the language, and an unambiguous grammar can be found that generates the same context-free language. However, there are certain languages that can only be generated by ambiguous grammars; such languages are called ''[[inherently ambiguous language]]s''.
| |
| | |
| == Normal forms ==
| |
| Every context-free grammar that does not generate the empty string can be transformed into one in which no rule has the empty string as a product [a rule with ε as a product is called an ε-production]. If it does generate the empty string, it will be necessary to include the rule <math>S \rarr \epsilon</math>, but there need be no other ε-rule. Every context-free grammar with no ε-production has an equivalent grammar in [[Chomsky normal form]] or [[Greibach normal form]]. "Equivalent" here means that the two grammars generate the same language.
| |
| | |
| Because of the especially simple form of production rules in Chomsky Normal Form grammars, this normal form has both theoretical and practical implications. For instance, given a context-free grammar, one can use the Chomsky Normal Form to construct a [[polynomial-time]] algorithm that decides whether a given string is in the language represented by that grammar or not (the [[CYK algorithm]]).
| |
| | |
| == Undecidable problems ==
| |
| Some questions that are undecidable for wider classes of grammars become decidable for context-free grammars; e.g. the emptiness problem (whether the grammar generates any terminal strings at all), is undecidable for [[context-sensitive grammar]]s, but decidable for context-free grammars.
| |
| | |
| Still, many problems remain undecidable. Examples are:
| |
| | |
| === Universality ===
| |
| | |
| Given a CFG, does it generate the language of all strings over the alphabet of terminal symbols used in its rules?<ref name="sipser">{{harvtxt|Sipser|1997}}, Theorem 5.10, p. 181.</ref><ref name="hu281"/>
| |
| | |
| A reduction can be demonstrated to this problem from the well-known undecidable problem of determining whether a [[Turing machine]] accepts a particular input (the [[Halting problem]]). The reduction uses the concept of a ''[[computation history]]'', a string describing an entire computation of a [[Turing machine]]. A CFG can be constructed that generates all strings that are not accepting computation histories for a particular Turing machine on a particular input, and thus it will accept all strings only if the machine doesn't accept that input.
| |
| | |
| === Language equality ===
| |
| Given two CFGs, do they generate the same language?<ref name="hu281">{{harvtxt|Hopcroft|Ullman|1979}}, p. 281.</ref><ref name="eom"/>
| |
| | |
| The undecidability of this problem is a direct consequence of the previous: it is impossible to even decide whether a CFG is equivalent to the trivial CFG defining the language of all strings.
| |
| | |
| === Language inclusion ===
| |
| Given two CFGs, can the first one generate all strings that the second one can generate?<ref name="hu281"/><ref name="eom"/>
| |
| | |
| If this problem was decidable, then language equality could be decided, too: two CFGs G1 and G2 generate the same language if L(G1) is a subset of L(G2) and L(G2) is a subset of L(G1).
| |
| | |
| === Being in a lower or higher level of the Chomsky hierarchy ===
| |
| | |
| Using [[Greibach's theorem]], it can be shown that the two following problems are undecidable:
| |
| | |
| * Given a [[context-sensitive grammar]], does it describe a context-free language?
| |
| * Given a context-free grammar, does it describe a [[regular language]]?<ref name="hu281"/><ref name="eom">{{citation|title=Encyclopaedia of mathematics: an updated and annotated translation of the Soviet "Mathematical Encyclopaedia"|first=Michiel|last=Hazewinkel|publisher=Springer|year=1994|isbn=978-1-55608-003-6|at=Vol. IV, p. 56|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=s9F71NJxwzoC&pg=PA56}}.</ref>
| |
| | |
| === Grammar ambiguity ===
| |
| Given a CFG, is it [[Ambiguous grammar|ambiguous]]?
| |
| | |
| The undecidability of this problem follows from the fact that if an algorithm to determine ambiguity existed, the [[Post correspondence problem]] could be decided, which is known to be undecidable.
| |
| | |
| === Language disjointness ===
| |
| | |
| Given two CFGs, is there any string derivable from both grammars?
| |
| | |
| If this problem was decidable, the undecidable [[Post correspondence problem]] could be decided, too: given strings <math>\alpha_1, \ldots, \alpha_N, \beta_1, \ldots, \beta_N</math> over some alphabet <math>\{a_1, \ldots, a_k\}</math>, let the grammar G1 consist of the rule
| |
| :S → <math>\alpha_1</math> S <math>\beta_1^{rev}</math> | ... | <math>\alpha_N</math> S <math>\beta_N^{rev}</math> | <math>b</math>;
| |
| where <math>\beta_i^{rev}</math> denotes the [[String_(computer_science)#Reversal|reversed]] string <math>\beta_i</math> and <math>b</math> doesn't occur among the <math>a_i</math>; and let grammar G2 consist of the rule
| |
| :T → <math>a_1</math> T <math>a_1</math> | ... | <math>a_k</math> T <math>a_k</math> | <math>b</math>;
| |
| Then the Post problem given by <math>\alpha_1, \ldots, \alpha_N, \beta_1, \ldots, \beta_N</math> has a solution if and only if L(G1) and L(G2) share a derivable string.
| |
| | |
| == Extensions ==
| |
| An obvious way to extend the context-free grammar formalism is to allow nonterminals to have arguments, the values of which are passed along within the rules. This allows natural language features such as [[Agreement (linguistics)|agreement]] and [[reference]], and programming language analogs such as the correct use and definition of identifiers, to be expressed in a natural way. E.g. we can now easily express that in English sentences, the subject and verb must agree in number. In computer science, examples of this approach include [[affix grammar]]s, [[attribute grammar]]s, [[indexed grammar]]s, and Van Wijngaarden [[two-level grammar]]s. Similar extensions exist in linguistics.
| |
| | |
| An '''extended context-free grammar''' is one in which the right-hand side of the production rules is allowed to be a [[regular expression]] over the grammar's terminals and nonterminals. Extended context-free grammars describe exactly the context-free languages.<ref>{{cite web | url=http://www.engr.mun.ca/~theo/Courses/fm/pub/context-free.pdf | title=A Short Introduction to Regular Expressions and Context-Free Grammars | accessdate=August 24, 2012 | author=Norvell, Theodore | pages=4}}</ref>
| |
| | |
| Another extension is to allow additional terminal symbols to appear at the left hand side of rules, constraining their application. This produces the formalism of [[context-sensitive grammar]]s.
| |
| | |
| == Subclasses ==
| |
| | |
| There are a number of important subclasses of the context-free grammars:
| |
| | |
| * [[LR parser|LR(''k'')]] grammars (also known as [[deterministic context-free grammar]]s) allow [[parsing]] (string recognition) with [[deterministic pushdown automaton|deterministic pushdown automata]], but they can only describe [[deterministic context-free language]]s.
| |
| | |
| * [[SLR grammar|Simple LR]], [[LALR parser|Look-Ahead LR]] grammars are subclasses that allow further simplification of parsing.
| |
| | |
| * [[LL parser|LL(''k'') and LL(''*'')]] grammars allow parsing by direct construction of a leftmost derivation as described above, and describe even fewer languages.
| |
| | |
| * [[Simple grammar]]s are a subclass of the LL(1) grammars mostly interesting for its theoretical property that language equality of simple grammars is decidable, while language inclusion is not.
| |
| | |
| * [[Bracketed grammar]]s have the property that the terminal symbols are divided into left and right bracket pairs that always match up in rules.
| |
| | |
| * [[Linear grammar]]s have no rules with more than one nonterminal in the right hand side.
| |
| | |
| * [[Regular grammar]]s are a subclass of the linear grammars and describe the [[regular language|regular]] languages, i.e. they correspond to [[finite automaton|finite automata]] and [[regular expression]]s.
| |
| | |
| LR parsing extends LL parsing to support a larger range of grammars; in turn, [[GLR parser|generalized LR parsing]] extends LR parsing to support arbitrary context-free grammars. On LL grammars and LR grammars, it essentially performs LL parsing and LR parsing, respectively, while on nondeterministic grammars, it is as efficient as can be expected. Although GLR parsing was developed in the 1980s, many new language definitions and [[parser generator]]s continue to be based on LL, LALR or LR parsing up to the present day.
| |
| | |
| ==Linguistic applications==
| |
| | |
| [[Noam Chomsky|Chomsky]] initially hoped to overcome the limitations of context-free grammars by adding [[transformational grammar|transformation rules]].<ref name="chomsky1956"/>
| |
| | |
| Such rules are another standard device in traditional linguistics; e.g. [[grammatical voice|passivization]] in English. Much of [[generative grammar]] has been devoted to finding ways of refining the descriptive mechanisms of phrase-structure grammar and transformation rules such that exactly the kinds of things can be expressed that natural language actually allows. Allowing arbitrary transformations doesn't meet that goal: they are much too powerful, being [[Turing complete]] unless significant restrictions are added (e.g. no transformations that introduce and then rewrite symbols in a context-free fashion).
| |
| | |
| Chomsky's general position regarding the non-context-freeness of natural language has held up since then,<ref name="shieber1985">{{citation | title=Evidence against the context-freeness of natural language | year=1985 | last=Shieber | first=Stuart | journal=Linguistics and Philosophy | volume=8 | pages=333–343 | url=http://www.eecs.harvard.edu/~shieber/Biblio/Papers/shieber85.pdf | doi=10.1007/BF00630917 | issue=3}}.</ref> although his specific examples regarding the inadequacy of context-free grammars in terms of their weak generative capacity were later disproved.<ref name="pullum-gazdar1982">{{citation | title=Natural languages and context-free languages | year=1982 | last=Pullum | first=Geoffrey K. | coauthors=Gerald Gazdar | journal=Linguistics and Philosophy | volume=4 | pages=471–504 | doi=10.1007/BF00360802 | issue=4}}.</ref>
| |
| [[Gerald Gazdar]] and [[Geoffrey Pullum]] have argued that despite a few non-context-free constructions in natural language (such as [[cross-serial dependencies]] in [[Swiss German]]<ref name="shieber1985"/> and [[reduplication]] in [[Bambara language|Bambara]]<ref name="culy1985">{{citation | title=The Complexity of the Vocabulary of Bambara | year=1985 | last=Culy | first=Christopher | journal=Linguistics and Philosophy | volume=8 | pages=345–351 | doi=10.1007/BF00630918 | issue=3}}.</ref>), the vast majority of forms in natural language are indeed context-free.<ref name="pullum-gazdar1982"/>
| |
| | |
| == See also ==
| |
| * [[Parsing expression grammar]]
| |
| * [[Stochastic context-free grammar]]
| |
| * [[Context-free grammar generation algorithms|Algorithms for context-free grammar generation]]
| |
| * [[Pumping lemma for context-free languages]]
| |
| | |
| === Parsing algorithms ===
| |
| * [[CYK algorithm]]
| |
| * [[GLR parser]]
| |
| * [[LL parser]]
| |
| * [[Earley algorithm]]
| |
| | |
| ==Notes==
| |
| {{Reflist|colwidth=30em}}
| |
| | |
| ==References==
| |
| *{{citation|first1=John E.|last1=Hopcroft|author1-link=John Hopcroft|first2=Jeffrey D.|last2=Ullman|author2-link=Jeffrey Ullman|title=Introduction to Automata Theory, Languages, and Computation|publisher=Addison-Wesley|year=1979}}. Chapter 4: Context-Free Grammars, pp. 77–106; Chapter 6: Properties of Context-Free Languages, pp. 125–137.
| |
| *{{citation|authorlink = Michael Sipser | first = Michael | last = Sipser | year = 1997 | title = Introduction to the Theory of Computation | publisher = PWS Publishing | isbn = 0-534-94728-X}}. Chapter 2: Context-Free Grammars, pp. 91–122; Section 4.1.2: Decidable problems concerning context-free languages, pp. 156–159; Section 5.1.1: Reductions via computation histories: pp. 176–183.
| |
| * {{cite book| author=J. Berstel, L. Boasson| title=Context-Free Languages| year=1990| volume=B| pages=59–102| publisher=Elsevier| editor=Jan van Leeuwen| series=Handbook of Theoretical Computer Science}}
| |
| | |
| {{Formal languages and grammars}}
| |
| | |
| {{DEFAULTSORT:Context-Free Grammar}}
| |
| [[Category:1956 in computer science]]
| |
| [[Category:Compiler construction]]
| |
| [[Category:Formal languages]]
| |
| [[Category:Programming language topics]]
| |
| [[Category:Wikipedia articles with ASCII art]]
| |
art Louis Vuitton Luggage Tag
Your Louis Vuitton Luggage Tag doctor, employer or accountant could be doing itwith your personal information. The Air Jordan 5 Retro Federal Trade Longchamp Wallet Women Commission recently warned nearly 100 organizations, including companies, schools and local governments, that the personal information of their customers and/or employees had been leaked onto online filesharing networks. The information found included Social Security numbers, health information, and driver's licensesmore than enough information for any identity thief to successfully steal someone's identity..
They're essential for conveying instructions and solving technical problems. Nobody holding a screwdriver, camera, or have a blank screen on their computer wants "fat" words. You simply frustrate them, maybe make them furious. Tanner always did love challenging. He spent a lot of nights resting on that boat in guest docks until he finally wore out his welcome. He then decided to sail out, even though he'd only ever sailed once before that.
Ideal for longtime Boston residents as well as visitors to Beantown. In addition it also provides this info for any agencies supported by Nextbus, CTA, Trimet, BART and OneBusAway. Platform : Web Android 2.2+ Desktop iPhone (Web) Boston Subway Created for the first time visitor and experienced commuter.
This is a great outside the box thought. If I were the Texans, I would say, ok let me shop Matt Schaub. Matt Schaub caused Kyle Shanahan in Houston, Shanahan, the Redskins OC. The Red Cross Gets 'Slizzerd'In February, the Red Cross's social media specialist Gloria Huang mistakenly posted a personal tweet on the company's feed. "We've deleted the rogue tweet but rest assured the Red Cross is sober and we've confiscated the keys," an explanatory Red Cross tweet said. Dogfish Head retweeted the "gettingslizzerd" hashtag and encouraged people to donate to the Red Cross..
The data presented in Aisle7 is for informational purposes only. It is based on scientific studies (human, animal, or perhaps in vitro), clinical experience, or traditional usage as cited in each article. The results reported may not necessarily occur in all individuals.
Use of the word casino is a facility modern use in some countries does not necessarily. Arts Entertainment: Whether your interests lie in Nike Air Force 1 Australia Online literature, art, movies, music or theatre, find helpful How To advice from eHow's stable of arts and. Future Media Architects is definitely an Internet development company with a global presence.
Despite his ranting against Jewish businessmen Hitler saw the Jews as the 'biological root' of Bolshevism. Most, like Ernst Toller and Erich Mhsam, for example, were idealistic utopians. They were not conspirators or traitors or anything of this sort.
where it is Timberland Shoes Sydney Stores
If you are only interested in activities, other privately run campgrounds is going to do just as well. And those are a dime twelve. This one is unique for its excellent hike and natural beauty. We encourage you to report abuse, but the decision to delete is ours. Commenters don't have any expectation of privacy and could be held accountable for their comments. Please watch our Terms of Use and Online privacy policy for further details..
Be sure to stick to the same rule yourself whenever your child's door is shut. I took her to my Ob appointments, whereby the room they had several diagrams from the uterus, where it is, and also the full meal deal of Timberland Shoes Sydney Stores delivery. It human people! My doctor flat out said "I wish every parent would explain and teach there children about the science of life.".
CSS includes a growing and diverse staff of veteran foreign investigators who train local Chinese actors to operate undercover with them or alone. Their experience indicates that 47% of all employees in China are willing to sell information about their company, 29% were willing to copy company hard drives, and 25% were prepared to sell copies of keys and security codes. It is Adidas Js Wings 2.0 all a matter of price.
Aroma group adapted bad eating habits but the control group participants were obviously unable to do likewise, says Schieberle. We also found that in comparison to the other group, the control group had a smaller amount of the satiety hormone serotonin in their blood. findings show that aroma is capable of regulating satiety, concludes Schieberle.
3. Will always look for you in a crowd, when he finds you will behave like he doesn't see you. 4. Is really a special place, and it not going to be a cookie cutter deal in sense at all, Friedman said. Pride ourselves on doing creative real estate development with sensitivity, and we are thrilled to work with the church. Burley, manager of property for the church, said the development of new buildings will help to finance repair off its massive property..
I wish everyone in India opened their eyes like you have done. For some reason many people in Indian Metros (especially the so called crowd) look down on anyone religious, especially from the Hindu Religion. This is even displayed regularly in Bollywood movies in which the villain or clown is the religious Hindu..
This is the new design that I would like to implement. If you are using Firefox, you should see it as I see Pandora Birthstone Rings Australia it. However, if you work with IE, it is a mess. According to that Vibram Kso Trek Discontinued writing should also change," he says. But, as many articles since he received the Jnanpith Award for 2002 have pointed out, nobody expected a story like Hara Hara Sankara to leave his pen. Published in January 2005, the short novel has as its central incident the arrest of the Kanchi Sankaracharya.
for example Indian Ugg Outlet Moorabbin
I know my friend would appreciate it if you would stop this immature behavior and act like an adult. To disum this reble called Yau Yau in Jonglei state. Instead to go fight with unknow reason and your family have nothing to eat you can report the gun towards the government if gun shoot because of it self and do your owns family isues rather than dieing without feeding.
It is 'an appetite that's grown by 21 per cent in the last ten years.' Dr Wendy Doyle from the British Dietetic Association warns that 'the popularity of such food plays a big role in our growing rates of obesity.' The Health Survey for England, made in 1998, rates that '62 per cent of adults are now overweight or obese, a figure that's rising in the same rate as America, one of the fattest nations on the planet.' On the other hand, many towns have a variety of international dishes, for example Indian, Italian, Chinese, Greek and etc. In this way they allow to try different tastes around the globe. 'Most towns have an Indian restaurant, serving foods for example curry and chicken tikka masala.
She is clearly pregnant and that i could see this from all the old posts too. Just because Ash has sharam and lajja does not mean she is trying to hide something. She is just trying to protect her unborn baby from bad luck and evil eye. Youngsters are often automatically covered by a household dental care insuranceor dental maintenance plan. Sometimes, you can add children to individual or family dental careinsurance or dental maintenance plans. Some dental maintenance plan providers offer special cover children, which parents can purchase.
Antony, patronsaint of seafarers, to whom the feast is dedicated. It was put up by a prosperous fisherman in the early 20th century. But there is no shelter, no food, and absolutely nothing to sightsee, except the choppy blue waters of the Palk Straits all round.
An "Inferiority complex" is a very bad thing. It causes one to become a bore by constant praise of self, hoping to find approval and agreement from others. But an "inferior feeling" can be devastating. Look no more. Get immediate access. 80 million + titles.
Residing in a material Ugg Outlet Moorabbin world. A radioactive material world, jokes charge singer. Isn the future we hoped for. Add in Timberland Factory Outlet Melbourne the absolute brainwrenching, Longchamp Le Pliage Large gut blasting video and that i begin to get a handle on why I sometimes have this fantasy of just living Longchamp Bags Ebay Australia somewhere like St. Helena island (the area Napoleon was exiled to the second time, where he died). It has been known as the most remote town on earth.
and young adults Air Jordan 11 Concord
"These are all things people loved to complete when the economy was better," Mason said. 7 in Chinatown. At least 20 people had to buy the groupon by June 7 to ensure that the restaurant to give the group the discount. As children, teens, and teenagers, these specific skills need to be practiced and shut relationships must be developed or else adult relationships will suffer. Consequently, brains may begin to be rewired in the future to not include these skills like empathy if they are not utilized as children (Stout, 2011). Each one of these consequences cause an increasing failure of relationships in teenagers, therefore, action must be taken against it..
I know I hate spending money on maternity clothes. I mean, they're only useful for a couple of months, right? Well, this shirt is made with a touch of spandex and an empire waistline to be forgiving for your expanding belly during pregnancy. But makes a great tunic after pregnany as well.
both on the hard disk for storage as well as in RAM during use. The Map Engine displays rich, detailed maps to be used in server or client applications. GeoBase uses the standard color schemes found Air Jordan 11 Concord in Mappoint TM, MapQuestTM along with other premier GIS solutions.
So, I wrote him an e-mail saying: Hello Mr. James, When must i expect you to be back in the states? I'd prefer to begin working with you once I've met you. This is merely out of precaution to safeguard myself from craigslist scams. They close the gate at Mens Polo Shirts Australia night so there was nothing very secure concerning the spot in which we stayed. We had to go on the other side of the cyclone fence Abercrombie Melbourne to be able to access our hookups. The spots within the fence were very unlevel and some were very short.
I've accessed the site from the browser on my small Blackberry 7100t, but the slowness of TMobile's network prohibits me from doing that too often. One capability that I Isabel Marant Sneaker Sale think would be useful would be the ability to post articles or comment on existing ones via SMS or email. This way somebody could compose a note on their mobile device, while located on the bus during their morning commute, and send it all at once without having to worry about keeping an energetic browser connection for a long period of your time.
The thing that I missed most from the tour was competitive spirit. Rehabbing is just boring. I want to play. One individual in the relationship is being more selfish than the other. What happens is that with separate accounts it becomes a rivalry from the beginning. I bought this with my money.