Definable real number: Difference between revisions
en>Ohconfucius m General formatting, inc. removal of superscripted ordinals |
en>Mr. Granger Repairing links to disambiguation pages - You can help! |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
A [[real number]] ''a'' is '''first-order definable in the language of set theory, without parameters''', if there is a formula ''φ'' in the language of [[set theory]], with one [[free variable]], such that ''a'' is the unique real number such that ''φ(a)'' holds in the standard model of set theory (see Kunen 1980:153). | |||
For the purposes of this article, such reals will be called simply '''''definable numbers'''''. This should not be understood to be standard terminology. | |||
Note that this definition cannot be expressed in the language of set theory itself. | |||
==General facts== | |||
Assuming they form a set, the definable numbers form a [[field (mathematics)|field]] containing all the familiar real numbers such as [[Zero|0]], [[One|1]], [[Pi|{{pi}}]], [[E_(mathematical_constant)|''e'']], et cetera. In particular, this field contains all the numbers named in the [[mathematical constant]]s article, and all [[algebraic number]]s (and therefore all [[rational number]]s). However, most real numbers are not definable: the [[Set (mathematics)|set]] of all definable numbers is [[countably infinite]] (because the set of all logical formulas is) while the set of real numbers is [[uncountable set|uncountably infinite]] (see [[Cantor's diagonal argument]]). As a result, [[almost all|most]] real numbers have no description (in the same sense of "most" as 'most real numbers are not rational'). | |||
The field of definable numbers is not [[complete space|complete]]; there exist convergent [[sequence]]s of definable numbers whose [[limit of a sequence|limit]] is not definable (since every real number is the limit of a sequence of rational numbers). However, if the sequence itself is definable in the sense that we can specify a single formula for all its terms, then its limit will necessarily be a definable number. | |||
While every [[computable number]] is definable, the converse is not true: the numeric representations of the [[Halting problem]], [[Chaitin's constant]], the truth set of first order arithmetic, and [[Zero sharp|0<sup>#</sup>]] are examples of numbers that are definable but not computable. Many other such numbers are known. | |||
One may also wish to talk about definable [[complex number]]s: complex numbers which are uniquely defined by a logical formula. However, whether this is possible depends on how the field of complex numbers is derived in the first place: it may not be possible to distinguish a complex number from its conjugate (say, 3+i from 3-i), since it is impossible to find a property of one that is not also a property of the other, without falling back on the underlying set-theoretic definition. Assuming we can define at least one nonreal complex number, however, a [[complex number]] is definable if and only if both its real part and its imaginary part are definable. The definable complex numbers also form a field if they form a set. | |||
The related concept of "standard" numbers, which can only be defined within a finite time and space, is used to motivate axiomatic [[internal set theory]], and provide a workable formulation for [[illimited number|illimited]] and [[infinitesimal number]]. Definitions of the hyper-real line within [[non-standard analysis]] (the subject area dealing with such numbers) overwhelmingly include the usual, uncountable set of real numbers as a subset. | |||
==Notion does not exhaust "unambiguously described" numbers== | |||
Not every number that we would informally say has been unambiguously described, is definable in the above sense. For example, if we can enumerate all such definable numbers by the [[Gödel number]]s of their defining formulas then we can use [[Cantor's diagonal argument]] to find a particular real that is not first-order definable in the same language. The argument can be made as follows: | |||
Suppose that in a mathematical language L, it is possible to enumerate all of the defined numbers in L. Let this enumeration be defined by the function G: W → R, where G(n) is the real number described by the nth description in the sequence. Using the diagonal argument, it is possible to define a real number x, which is not equal to G(n) for any n. This means that there is a language L' that defines x, which is undefinable in L. | |||
==Other notions of definability== | |||
The notion of definability treated in this article has been chosen primarily for definiteness, not on the grounds that it's more useful or interesting than other notions. Here we treat a few others: | |||
===Definability in other languages or structures=== | |||
====Language of arithmetic==== | |||
The [[language of arithmetic]] has symbols for 0, 1, the successor operation, addition, and multiplication, intended to be interpreted in the usual way over the [[natural number]]s. Since no variables of this language range over the [[real number]]s, we cannot simply copy the earlier definition of definability. Rather, we say that a real ''a'' is '''''definable in the language of arithmetic''''' (or '''''[[arithmetical hierarchy|arithmetical]]''''') if its [[Dedekind cut]] can be defined as a [[Predicate (logic)|predicate]] in that language; that is, if there is a first-order formula ''φ'' in the language of arithmetic, with two free variables, such that | |||
:<math>\forall m \, \forall n \, (\varphi(n,m)\iff\frac{n}{m}<a).</math> | |||
====2nd-order language of arithmetic==== | |||
The second-order language of arithmetic is the same as the first-order language, except that variables and quantifiers are allowed to range over sets of naturals. A real that is second-order definable in the language of arithmetic is called '''''[[analytical hierarchy|analytical]]'''''. | |||
===Definability with ordinal parameters=== | |||
Sometimes it is of interest to consider definability ''with parameters''; that is, to give a definition relative to another object that remains undefined. For example, a real ''a'' (or for that matter, any set ''a'') is called '''''ordinal definable''''' if there is a first-order formula ''φ'' in the language of set theory, with ''two'' free variables, and an [[Ordinal number|ordinal]] γ, such that ''a'' is the unique object such that ''φ''(''a'',γ) holds (in V). | |||
The other sorts of definability thus far considered have only countably many defining formulas, and therefore allow only countably many definable reals. This is not true for ordinal definability, because an ordinal definable real is defined not only by the formula ''φ'', but also by the ordinal γ. In fact it is consistent with [[ZFC]] that ''all'' reals are ordinal-definable, and therefore that there are uncountably many ordinal-definable reals. However it is also consistent with ZFC that there are only countably many ordinal-definable reals. | |||
== See also == | |||
* [[Berry paradox]] | |||
* [[Computable number]] | |||
* [[Constructible number]] | |||
* [[Constructible universe]] | |||
* [[Entscheidungsproblem]] | |||
==References== | |||
* {{Citation | last1=Kunen | first1=Kenneth | author1-link=Kenneth Kunen | title=[[Set Theory: An Introduction to Independence Proofs]] | publisher=North-Holland | location=Amsterdam | isbn=978-0-444-85401-8 | year=1980}} | |||
* [http://rothkamm.com/download.cfm/turing/Turing.pdf Alan Turing, "On Computable Numbers, With An Application to the Entscheidungsproblem", ''Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society'', 1936] ([[Alan Turing|Turing's]] original paper distinguishing computable and definable numbers) | |||
[[Category:Set theory]] |
Revision as of 04:39, 19 December 2013
A real number a is first-order definable in the language of set theory, without parameters, if there is a formula φ in the language of set theory, with one free variable, such that a is the unique real number such that φ(a) holds in the standard model of set theory (see Kunen 1980:153).
For the purposes of this article, such reals will be called simply definable numbers. This should not be understood to be standard terminology.
Note that this definition cannot be expressed in the language of set theory itself.
General facts
Assuming they form a set, the definable numbers form a field containing all the familiar real numbers such as 0, 1, Potter or Ceramic Artist Harry Rave from Cobden, spends time with hobbies for instance magic, property developers [https://www.manateegalleries.com/?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=user&id=30857 house in singapore] singapore and fitness. Finds inspiration through travel and just spent 7 months at Keoladeo National Park., e, et cetera. In particular, this field contains all the numbers named in the mathematical constants article, and all algebraic numbers (and therefore all rational numbers). However, most real numbers are not definable: the set of all definable numbers is countably infinite (because the set of all logical formulas is) while the set of real numbers is uncountably infinite (see Cantor's diagonal argument). As a result, most real numbers have no description (in the same sense of "most" as 'most real numbers are not rational').
The field of definable numbers is not complete; there exist convergent sequences of definable numbers whose limit is not definable (since every real number is the limit of a sequence of rational numbers). However, if the sequence itself is definable in the sense that we can specify a single formula for all its terms, then its limit will necessarily be a definable number.
While every computable number is definable, the converse is not true: the numeric representations of the Halting problem, Chaitin's constant, the truth set of first order arithmetic, and 0# are examples of numbers that are definable but not computable. Many other such numbers are known.
One may also wish to talk about definable complex numbers: complex numbers which are uniquely defined by a logical formula. However, whether this is possible depends on how the field of complex numbers is derived in the first place: it may not be possible to distinguish a complex number from its conjugate (say, 3+i from 3-i), since it is impossible to find a property of one that is not also a property of the other, without falling back on the underlying set-theoretic definition. Assuming we can define at least one nonreal complex number, however, a complex number is definable if and only if both its real part and its imaginary part are definable. The definable complex numbers also form a field if they form a set.
The related concept of "standard" numbers, which can only be defined within a finite time and space, is used to motivate axiomatic internal set theory, and provide a workable formulation for illimited and infinitesimal number. Definitions of the hyper-real line within non-standard analysis (the subject area dealing with such numbers) overwhelmingly include the usual, uncountable set of real numbers as a subset.
Notion does not exhaust "unambiguously described" numbers
Not every number that we would informally say has been unambiguously described, is definable in the above sense. For example, if we can enumerate all such definable numbers by the Gödel numbers of their defining formulas then we can use Cantor's diagonal argument to find a particular real that is not first-order definable in the same language. The argument can be made as follows:
Suppose that in a mathematical language L, it is possible to enumerate all of the defined numbers in L. Let this enumeration be defined by the function G: W → R, where G(n) is the real number described by the nth description in the sequence. Using the diagonal argument, it is possible to define a real number x, which is not equal to G(n) for any n. This means that there is a language L' that defines x, which is undefinable in L.
Other notions of definability
The notion of definability treated in this article has been chosen primarily for definiteness, not on the grounds that it's more useful or interesting than other notions. Here we treat a few others:
Definability in other languages or structures
Language of arithmetic
The language of arithmetic has symbols for 0, 1, the successor operation, addition, and multiplication, intended to be interpreted in the usual way over the natural numbers. Since no variables of this language range over the real numbers, we cannot simply copy the earlier definition of definability. Rather, we say that a real a is definable in the language of arithmetic (or arithmetical) if its Dedekind cut can be defined as a predicate in that language; that is, if there is a first-order formula φ in the language of arithmetic, with two free variables, such that
2nd-order language of arithmetic
The second-order language of arithmetic is the same as the first-order language, except that variables and quantifiers are allowed to range over sets of naturals. A real that is second-order definable in the language of arithmetic is called analytical.
Definability with ordinal parameters
Sometimes it is of interest to consider definability with parameters; that is, to give a definition relative to another object that remains undefined. For example, a real a (or for that matter, any set a) is called ordinal definable if there is a first-order formula φ in the language of set theory, with two free variables, and an ordinal γ, such that a is the unique object such that φ(a,γ) holds (in V).
The other sorts of definability thus far considered have only countably many defining formulas, and therefore allow only countably many definable reals. This is not true for ordinal definability, because an ordinal definable real is defined not only by the formula φ, but also by the ordinal γ. In fact it is consistent with ZFC that all reals are ordinal-definable, and therefore that there are uncountably many ordinal-definable reals. However it is also consistent with ZFC that there are only countably many ordinal-definable reals.
See also
References
- Many property agents need to declare for the PIC grant in Singapore. However, not all of them know find out how to do the correct process for getting this PIC scheme from the IRAS. There are a number of steps that you need to do before your software can be approved.
Naturally, you will have to pay a safety deposit and that is usually one month rent for annually of the settlement. That is the place your good religion deposit will likely be taken into account and will kind part or all of your security deposit. Anticipate to have a proportionate amount deducted out of your deposit if something is discovered to be damaged if you move out. It's best to you'll want to test the inventory drawn up by the owner, which can detail all objects in the property and their condition. If you happen to fail to notice any harm not already mentioned within the inventory before transferring in, you danger having to pay for it yourself.
In case you are in search of an actual estate or Singapore property agent on-line, you simply should belief your intuition. It's because you do not know which agent is nice and which agent will not be. Carry out research on several brokers by looking out the internet. As soon as if you end up positive that a selected agent is dependable and reliable, you can choose to utilize his partnerise in finding you a home in Singapore. Most of the time, a property agent is taken into account to be good if he or she locations the contact data on his website. This may mean that the agent does not mind you calling them and asking them any questions relating to new properties in singapore in Singapore. After chatting with them you too can see them in their office after taking an appointment.
Have handed an trade examination i.e Widespread Examination for House Brokers (CEHA) or Actual Property Agency (REA) examination, or equal; Exclusive brokers are extra keen to share listing information thus making certain the widest doable coverage inside the real estate community via Multiple Listings and Networking. Accepting a severe provide is simpler since your agent is totally conscious of all advertising activity related with your property. This reduces your having to check with a number of agents for some other offers. Price control is easily achieved. Paint work in good restore-discuss with your Property Marketing consultant if main works are still to be done. Softening in residential property prices proceed, led by 2.8 per cent decline within the index for Remainder of Central Region
Once you place down the one per cent choice price to carry down a non-public property, it's important to accept its situation as it is whenever you move in – faulty air-con, choked rest room and all. Get round this by asking your agent to incorporate a ultimate inspection clause within the possibility-to-buy letter. HDB flat patrons routinely take pleasure in this security net. "There's a ultimate inspection of the property two days before the completion of all HDB transactions. If the air-con is defective, you can request the seller to repair it," says Kelvin.
15.6.1 As the agent is an intermediary, generally, as soon as the principal and third party are introduced right into a contractual relationship, the agent drops out of the image, subject to any problems with remuneration or indemnification that he could have against the principal, and extra exceptionally, against the third occasion. Generally, agents are entitled to be indemnified for all liabilities reasonably incurred within the execution of the brokers´ authority.
To achieve the very best outcomes, you must be always updated on market situations, including past transaction information and reliable projections. You could review and examine comparable homes that are currently available in the market, especially these which have been sold or not bought up to now six months. You'll be able to see a pattern of such report by clicking here It's essential to defend yourself in opposition to unscrupulous patrons. They are often very skilled in using highly unethical and manipulative techniques to try and lure you into a lure. That you must also protect your self, your loved ones, and personal belongings as you'll be serving many strangers in your home. Sign a listing itemizing of all of the objects provided by the proprietor, together with their situation. HSR Prime Recruiter 2010
- Alan Turing, "On Computable Numbers, With An Application to the Entscheidungsproblem", Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society, 1936 (Turing's original paper distinguishing computable and definable numbers)